Resource Screening Checklist (Demonstration)


Metadata Review:
Enter the GUID for this resource:
Enter the e-mail address of the reviewer: 
     1.  Are all major words in the title capitalized and is the grammar correct?
          OK            Needs Work
     2.  Does the description have correct sentence structure, including proper capitalization 
          and grammar?
          OK            Needs Work    
Metadata fields 3 - 9 are required.  If you believe that there is an error or other 
problem with one of these required fields, describe the problem in the comment field.
     3.  Role (if the role is "submitter", there must be an author and/or publisher role filled in)
          OK            Needs Work    
     4.  Last Name
          OK            Needs Work    
     5.  eMail Address
          OK            Needs Work    
     6.  Title
          OK            Needs Work    
     7.  URL (test the link and note any problems)
          OK            Needs Work    
     8.  Taxonomy
          OK            Needs Work    
     9.  Cost and Copyright
          OK            Needs Work    
     10.  Keywords (should not be repeated from the title or description)
          OK            Needs Work    
     11.  Learning Resource Type

          OK          Needs  Work     Should be:

     12.  Interactivity

          OK          Needs  Work     Should be:

     13.  Difficulty

          OK          Needs  Work     Should be:

     14.  End User Role

          OK          Needs  Work     Should be:

     15.  Structure

          OK          Needs  Work     Should be:

     16.  Other Metadata Elements (describe all other metadata problems)
          OK            Needs Work     
 
Content Review:
 
     17.  Is the content accurate for the intended audience?
          Yes           Needs Work    
     18.  Are pictures, equations, diagrams, etc. appropriate and supportive 
            of the content?

          Yes           Needs Work    
     19.  Is it clear to the intended audience how the resource should/could be used 
            or how it works?

          Yes           Needs Work    
 
Technical Review:
 
     20.  Does the resource work the way it is supposed to?
          Yes           Needs Work    
     21.  Are all technical requirements complete and clearly described?
          Yes           Needs Work    
     22.  Are all images of good quality and easily read or viewed?
          Yes           Needs Work    
 
Overall Rating:
 
            Acceptable for iLumina as is.
            Acceptable for iLumina after revisions noted in review.  No need for a second review.
            Acceptable for iLumina after revisions noted in review.  Must be reviewed again.
            Not acceptable.